This is a tricky question for the Red Sox.
What should they do?
1. Try and win the division, and by that I mean really, really try to win out and clinch the American League East title and probable best record throughout the A.L. playoffs.
Positives: Play the majority of games at Fenway Park, where the Sox have a distinct homefield advantage for obvious reasons … It would be a good way of heading into the playoffs, with a little notch on their belts … Going to Anaheim for three potential games, including a one-game finale if series is tied 2-2 could be a killer … Finally, winning the division ahead of the Yankees for the first time in a decade.
Negatives: You’re in the playoffs. That’s the only thing that should matter. Why expend energy and possibly messing with the rotation heading into the playoffs … Some players need rest, not including the guys who are injured (Manny Ramirez and Kevin Youkilis). You may lose the chance of giving a guys “mental” breaks for a few days … Homefield advantage doesn’t really matter in the playoffs. So why care about it. It comes down to pitching … Plus, wild card teams are just as likely to win as division winners (see Red Sox in 2004 and Cardinals in 2006).
I believe the positives outweigh the negatives. Winning the division is not as important as having the best record … But let’s be honest, there is a chest-thumping thing that goes with finally edging out the Yankees for once in the division. The Red Sox should not try to win “at all costs” but going all out through the middle of next week, trying to clinch the division and best record, is worth benefits.
The Sox players are on record as saying they want the division title, as a badge of honor. I agree, at least for now, to try and get it, sooner rather than later.
What are your thoughts?